Tuesday, 3 February 2026

PART I, ARTICLE VI: THE SYMBOL OF POWER IN THE CHURCHES OF GOD, SECTION I

 


This study on the symbol of power is the first major article that I produced as a Christian. The first half of 1 Corinthians 11 so arrested me with its order and subject matter that I was driven to focus on it for some months, which impulse I gladly surrendered to. The glory of this passage made me glad to overflowing; and this gladness was induced by the Lord, I think, because I was grieved that the principles in the passage, and the passage itself, were being neglected and abused. This part of sacred Scripture continues to be passed over or deceitfully treated since the first time that the Lord loved me through it. There is no portion of God’s word that I see more clearly than this one. No portion dazzles me by the arrangement of its revelation more than this one does.  

“For this cause ought the woman to have power on her head because of the angels” (1 Corinthians 11.10.) 

The Corinthian letters are epistles of correction that the apostle Paul sent to a carnal, contentious church. Frequently an exasperated tone is noticeable in these letters, as in, “This is the third time I am coming to you…I told you before….” (2 Corinthians 13.1, 2.) There are three easy ways to get a sense of what was going on in this church when it received its letters of correction. We can read the letters. We can read Romans 1, which was written from Corinth, and which is revealing of the sins that were practiced there. Or we can visit a sign-seeking church. The church at Corinth was quarrelsome and disorderly, and allowed licentious behavior to go unpunished.    

The disorder addressed in the first half of chapter 11 has to do with disobedience to God’s appointed authority structure. The rule that was being disobeyed is encapsulated by the phrase, ‘power on her head,’ in verse 10. While the KJV’s ‘power on her head’ is the more eloquent way of stating the injunction, the NKJV better conveys the sense with, ‘symbol of authority on her head.’ The matter is best understood, however, as a ‘symbol of subjection.’ The terminology makes little difference because the rest of the passage throws abundant light on the subject. The idea is that the woman should have a token to symbolize that she is under power— under authority. The symbol is the mark by which we may observe that the woman is under power; that is, in subjection to man. Therefore, to state that she needs a ‘symbol of power on her head’ is perhaps the best way to say it, after all. The sense is that the woman should have her head covered in church in order to symbolize her subordination to man. The tradition has to do with church order, which order points to the salvation that Christians have in common. Therefore, it is something that ‘angels desire to look into’ (1 Peter 1.12.) Angels observe what goes on in the world (Job 1.) Especially do they concern themselves with what goes on in God’s Church. The apostles were ‘made a spectacle,’ not only to the world, but ‘to angels’ (1 Corinthians 4.9.) In verse 10 of chapter 11, the power on the head of woman is said to be necessary ‘because of the angels.’ It is one argument out of many that the apostle posits for the continuance of the tradition, which tradition may be simply stated as: Women should cover their heads during church services. 

The passage of Scripture that 1 Corinthians 11.10 is in the center of may seem, at first glance, ambiguous. But stare into it for a few months, and a simple message and sublime revelation manifest. The passage begins at verse 2 with, ‘Now I praise you, brethren.’ This is similar to how the next passage begins: ‘Now in this that I declare unto you’ (verse 17.) So the message of correction concerning the symbol of power begins with ‘now,’ which is the same way that the word of correction regarding the Lord’s Supper begins. The correction that comes after that, the one concerning spiritual gifts in chapter 12, begins in like manner. 

The passage in question begins with three statements: the tradition is an ‘ordinance’ that we should ‘keep’ (verse 2); it is based on an authority structure that includes Christ and God (verse 3); and it involves every praying man and praying woman (verses 4 and 5.) The statements are followed by a series of arguments in support of the ordinance: the uncovered head of woman is a shame that is comparable to a woman’s hair being shorn (verses 5, 6); God’s glory (the man) is displayed without rival when the woman’s head is covered (verse 7), which argument is bolstered by the creative order of man and woman and the purpose of woman for the man (verses 8, 9); and these facts are important to exemplify because angels are looking on (verse 10.) At this point, in verses 11 and 12, the apostle perceives the need to safeguard against the oppression of woman by teaching her codependence with man ‘in the Lord.’ Then he closes with two arguments more: the symbol of power is consonant with nature (verses 13-15); and the churches of God should not be in the habit of being contentious about what has just been taught (verse 16.)              

It has become chic to scoff at any interpretation of Scripture that obliges an act of submission on the part of women, especially since women are so broadly permitted to officiate as ministers these days. What the Scriptures teach, however, is what we should go by, not what fashionable churches do. If the interpretation that is scoffed at is a faithful unfolding of the text in question, what does the scoffer scoff at but what the word of God teaches? And what is that but making fun of God’s word and of God himself? The importance of this passage should be obvious from its placement before, and connection with, the passage on Holy Communion. Respect for the authority structure established by God should precede an orderly Communication of Christ’s Body and Blood. And this is why the tradition is enforced in this place by God’s apostle. Is it not pitiful that some secular women are wearing veils in public to signal their virtue to Muslims, while Christian women will not veil themselves in church for the Saviour of their souls? 

The opening statements may be summed up in three points. These are: there is a custom to keep; there is a canon of authority to observe; there is contemptuous worship to avoid or repent of. Each point needs to be remarked on before coming to the arguments, which arguments demonstrate that disobedience to the tradition involves a comparable shame; that man and woman are creatures of glory; that they are surrounded by a cloud of witnesses; that the tradition is consonant with nature; and that the tradition is contested by no other church but the one in Corinth.


Monday, 2 February 2026

PART I, ARTICLE V: THE HOLY USE OF A CONFESSION OF FAITH, SECTION V

Separation from Inability 

The two objects of a Confession are to disclaim and confirm—to cast off error and to confirm saints in truth. By this edification we are lifted from the mire of inability. Ability is the consequence of knowing truth and being convinced of what is right. We become able men through understanding and passion. As we worship more in spirit and in truth, and are better disposed to walk in our pre-ordained sphere of usefulness, we come closer to realizing our chief end: ‘to glorify God, and to enjoy him forever,’ as the Westminster Catechism puts it. Revivals of religion are caused by persons who are capable, which capability is filtered through the influence of the Spirit upon the truth that they have been made sure of. Revivals are not full-blown at once; they begin through the Spirit’s use of a few individuals. The persons they begin with are not necessarily men who are well-known. Whoever gains understanding, conviction, and ability may be the next agent of spiritual change and moral reform. Revivals are not forwarded through persons who are confused, unsure, and incapable. They happen through persons who recognize their inability to make something spiritual happen except by a reliance on the Holy Spirit; but these persons are not ill-informed, uncertain, and inept. Apart from the fact of the Spirit’s own sovereignty to cause revival in his own place and time, what better answer do we have for revivals not happening than the fact that Christian leaders do not believe what they should believe? With few exceptions, the preachers of Great Awakening times were Confessional Christians of the Calvinist persuasion. 

The campaigns of our day are not in the same category as the revivals of yesterday. They are, like the booklet authored by Misters Taylor, McClurkin, and Mackay: Arminian efforts. There is a qualitative difference between revivals and campaigns. There is practically no effect on a city after a campaign or a ‘crusade’ has been waged. But historical records (such as those that have been written about the Welsh revival) show that the moral temper of whole towns and regions have been changed on account of revival. The disparity in effect between a campaign and a revival is on account of the one being pushed by man and the other being driven by the Spirit. Besides being saved from sins and their ultimate consequences, the reason for religion is to be spared, as much as possible, from the more immediate consequences of sin. Peaceful living is what God wants from us, with the increase and maintenance of good conduct and piety: the ‘quiet and peaceable life in all godliness and honesty’ (1 Timothy 2.2.) To this we arrive through separation from falsehood, uncertainty, and inability; and this is the way to society becoming decent and civilized. A revival of religion begins with Christians who reform and separate themselves from sin; then the revival of Christians is used by God to convert new sinners who leave off sinning; and then the blessed result from all of this inner peace is the peaceful community. Believing amiss will not begin this widening circle of moral improvement. To be cool in our convictions will not kindle our beliefs. And to be incorrect and unconvinced ensures our infirmity. When sermons from campaigns are compared with sermons used in revivals, the differences that stick out between the two involve about every part and characteristic of a sermon than can be thought of. Compared with revival sermons, campaign sermons exhibit scarcity of aptitude generally; and dearth of artistry, intelligence, and intensity particularly. Without aptitude for the work, a sermon is dead before it begins to be uttered, and goes out from the mouth like an ejected corpse. Without artistry, the sermon is undressed. Without intelligence, the sermon elicits no thought. Without intensity, the sermon arrests no attention. That, in few words, is the condition of a campaign sermon. It is as dead as a corpse. It is dead; it is ugly; it is thoughtless; it is uninteresting. The lack of intelligence, or doctrinal density, in the sermons of our day should not be blamed on the dissimilarity of eras. Preachers are less educated today than they were a century or more ago. But what has time to do with it? The cause of dullness is the belief that dullness should be adequate to produce the effect that a sermon should produce. More material for one’s education is available than ever before. So there is no excuse for being a dullard, no matter what year it is and no matter what seminary a person has graduated from. Between contemporary sermons and the sermons of yore, the difference in intensity is just as noticeable as the intellectual disparity. It is well-known that a sermon on the page is flat compared to the hearing of it; yet, even given that, the sermons on the page from revival days are more noticeably alive than what we hear from the pulpits of our greatest living preachers. If we are more affected from reading a sermon, like one by R. M. M’Cheyne, for example, than by listening to a preacher down the street—if we detect more fervor in the former than in the latter—then today’s ministers must be lacking animation indeed. Men who are more doctrinally correct have, usually, deeper conviction and more success. The Holy Spirit will be more upon the preacher who worships most in spirit and in truth. We lack this presence greatly today. The fire used to burn so hot that men could not but speak, just like it was for the apostles. Such men could be fired up by the gospel in an instant. It makes me think of a potbellied stove that can become too hot to touch within a minute of being lit. By the time you get to your chair, you have to return because the lid is lifting and sparks are shooting out the draft. Having the answers, and knowing that you have them, is a highly combustible mix. This fuel, once lit, may burn itself into ashes; a great preacher’s body, like a burning sun, must consume itself. It is my opinion, from reading accounts of revival, that many preachers have been guilty of overwork. But it is more honorable to burn out than to barely burn. Howell Harris was one such notable preacher. In 1766, Henry Venn, another great preacher, related this about the man:

“Howell Harris is the father of that settlement [Trevecka, in Wales], and the founder. After labouring for fifteen years, more violently than any of the servants of Christ, in this revival, he was so hurt in body as to be confined to his own house for seven years. Upon the beginning of this confinement, first one, and then another, whom the Lord had converted under His word, to the number of near a hundred, came and desired to live with him, and that they would work and get their bread…Of all the people I ever saw, this society seems to be the most advanced in grace. They speak as men and women who feel themselves every moment worthy of eternal punishment, and infinitely base; and yet, at the same time, have such certainty of salvation through the second man, the Lord from heaven, as is indeed delightful to behold” (Henry Venn, The Letters of Henry Venn, pp. 121, 122.) 

That is what can happen when we free ourselves from error, when we shake off uncertainty, and when, because of that, the shackles of inability fall off. Howell Harris was certain of what he believed; and his preaching produced likeminded converts. By being correct, and then by deeply believing that we are correct, we can trust our work, we can trust that God will bless it, and we will reap the blessing. If we happen to be correct in our beliefs but have little conviction, who will believe us? If we are convinced of wrong beliefs, our strong believing will mislead others. A Confession can make a man correct; and conviction added to correctness is the way to success in matters ministerial. A man must be right, and he must know that he is right; only then is he fit to present God to men, ethical matters and personal piety taken as granted, for they are not part of my thesis. Holiness has much to do with purity of doctrine. Our beliefs must be as separate from falsehoods as the vessels used by Aaron were kept apart from vessels of the common sort.   

When conviction is added to a proper understanding of theology, stability is established, and familiarity with what is believed and understood has a chance to grow. That man is more convincing who can explain a thing from whatever angle the listener needs to hear it from. Do we believe that a man is familiar with a neighborhood if he can’t lead a person from any part of it to any other part of it without hesitation? The best men are those who trace everything back to the neighborhood of God’s will in eternity. They are accused, unfortunately, of believing in a guilty God because they embrace the truth that God’s mercy turns on his discriminating will. Stephen Charnock shows this accusation to be a false one:

“God could, if he would, savingly enlighten the minds of all men in the world, and quicken their hearts with a new life by an invincible grace; but in not doing it, there is no positive act of God, but a cessation of action. We may with as much reason say, that God is the cause of all the sinful actions that are committed by the corporation of devils, since their first rebellion, because he leaves them to themselves, and bestows not a new grace upon them,—as say, God is the cause of the sins of those that he overlooks and leaves in that state of guilt wherein he found them. God did not pass by any without the consideration of sin; so that this act of God is not repugnant to his holiness, but conformable to his justice” (Stephen Charnock, The Existence and Attributes of God.) 

Man is born in sin and dead in sin. His heart is hard by nature of who, and what, he is. God is the Creator of all else except himself. He is not obliged to choose, or to have chosen, from eternity, to have mercy on a hardened sinner. Separation from error is a necessary step to success in religion. We are not separate from error until we accept who God is and who man is. To worship God in spirit and in truth must involve liberation from falsehood, knowledge of truth, and certitude regarding the truth we profess. What are faith and practice worth when we knowingly remain in error about fundamental aspects of God’s word? We might find at last that their worth was not enough to gain entry into God’s kingdom. The use of a Confession of Faith will bring about the holy separation from error that is necessary to a proper practice of religion. The value of this use can be measured by how important it is to have impeccable notions about God. Even apart from the help of a Confession or even the Bible, it should be plain that any God worthy of the name must have a full and free right to dispose of his creatures as he sees fit. Man is responsible to repent and believe in spite of his incapacity, by himself, to do so; he is responsible for his sins even if God has not chosen him for salvation any more than he chose Pharaoh. It is God’s prerogative to do what he will with his creatures. “Shall the thing formed say to him that formed it, why hast thou made me thus?” (Romans 9.20.) This humiliating verse is good medicine. It is a healthy pill to swallow. Many refuse to swallow it, and do not become good physicians for others who are sick, remaining as they do, willfully sick and disabled themselves. They are addicted to false notions of God and man. 

It seems probable that God is worshipped in spirit in proportion to how much he is worshiped in truth. We worship God in truth by humbly accepting what the Bible teaches. We have much to thank God for in giving, not only Truth, but Confessions to explain this Truth, for they help to adroitly expose and overthrow, the falsehoods and heresies of men who would if they could, not let God be God.


Saturday, 31 January 2026

PART I, ARTICLE V: THE HOLY USE OF A CONFESSION OF FAITH, SECTION IV

Separation from Uncertainty 

By comparing what we read and hear beside a good Confession and Scripture, we will discover the worth of a Confession, and then through its use arrive at the strong conviction that is necessary for us to be impactful. A man who is tossed back and forth by shifting winds of doctrine will be of little use in helping others. He may be admired and followed; but he will raise nothing more by his nomadic mind than scatterbrained sheep. The word of God will not have power through us unless we are unwavering in setting this word forth. A Christian is not meant to believe with anything less than certain confidence. He will not be unwaveringly convinced until he studies. He should, therefore, study the best material. A search for that will lead him to Creeds and Confessions, the works of the men who composed them, and the works of the men who have followed the men who composed them. A pastor or teacher whose ideas are not fixed will have an unstable congregation. When a crisis occurs, the members will topple instead of stand; or if they stand, it will be uncertainly or for the wrong side of a cause. Without creedal guidance, a pastor sets his people up to be what the Bible calls ‘discomfited’ and ‘astonied,’ like when an army is suddenly overtaken by a terrible force. That terrible force may be Satan (by his temptations), the World (by its influences), God (by his tests), or even all three forces together like in what happened to Old Testament Job. Truth is an impenetrable fortress. But none of us can believe in truth to perfection; we all err on some points. Our fortress, practically speaking, is whatever body of doctrines we have come to believe in; in other words, our dogma. Do we have all of the essential bricks and blocks? Are they in their proper places? Unless our fortress is strong and secure, we risk being besieged, and then taken hostage by falsehoods. Through the careful use of a Confession, we begin to see that the Confession is true to Scripture and that many tricky books are proven to be farther from Scripture than our Confession is. This increases our trust in truth, and the doctrines begin to take hold of us in a deeper way. Through an able use of a Confession, by which we learn to withstand and confute the clever books that others are deceived by, we begin to understand the necessity of using one. 

This poisonous book that was found wanting alongside the Westminster Confession of Faith and Scripture—this pestilent Biblical Balance on Election & Free Will—was given to me by my spiritual mentor, a man who, because of his intemperate love for Brethrenism, was deceived by it. This shows with what care we must live our lives. Through this good and holy man I was almost duped to dismiss the facts from eternity that underlie the facts from history that I am saved by. It is because of an election from eternity that a sinner is saved by faith in Christ. It is because of predestination that a person’s lot is determined. It is because of facts like these that a sinner is awed about his salvation from sin. These facts are not unimportant. Because they emphasize something as notable as God’s eternal blueprint, we must know them, believe them, and be deeply convinced of their factuality. May God convince us of the importance of strong conviction! The use of Confessions, and the use of books written by men who have respected faithful creedal formulas, develops a well-ordered conviction in what we believe: 

“I question whether we have preached the whole counsel of God, unless predestination with all its solemnity and sureness be continually declared—unless election be boldly and nakedly taught as being one of the truths revealed of God. It is the minister’s duty, beginning from this fountainhead, to trace all the other streams; dwelling on effectual calling, maintaining justification by faith, insisting upon the certain perseverance of the believer, and delighting to proclaim that gracious covenant in which all these things are contained, and which is sure to all the chosen, blood-bought seed. There is a tendency in this age to throw doctrinal truth into the shade. Too many preachers are offended with that stern truth which the Covenanters held, and to which the Puritans testified in the midst of a licentious age…The faithful minister must be plain, simple, pointed, with regard to these doctrines. There must be no dispute about whether he believes them or not” (C. H. Spurgeon, The Minister’s Farewell.)

Are we not struck by the doubtless tone in a passage like that? A man who is certain about what he believes, provided that what he believes is true, is more likely to be used by God than a man who is afraid of sounding dogmatic. No Christian has a right to be ashamed of God’s word, even if that word teaches the Calvinistic beliefs that are never in favor with easily offended, mushy Christians. Spurgeon knew better than to soak the pristine doctrines of Election and Sovereignty in the muddy waters of modernism, which was already a rushing tide in his day. He preached responsibility beside predestination; and, because he was confirmed in truth, he was not troubled in the least by the apparent disharmony. The Spirit descended upon his ministry, in large part, because of his theological convictions. 

Another well-known example of the salutary effect of confidence is the life of Francis Schaeffer, the Christian philosopher, who happens to have been a creedal Calvinist as well. He was not used by God in a thorough way until he had a crisis about truth, which crisis catapulted him back to the beginning to reexamine everything. He came out of this trial with the same beliefs; but he was renewed through knowing for certain that he had been right. Then the shelter that he opened in the Alps became the place of refuge for people seeking philosophical answers to the great questions of life. I have often read his account of that crisis, for it is a lesson on how a great work is born: 

“In 1951 and 1952 I faced a spiritual crisis in my own life…I told Edith that for the sake of honesty I had to go all the way back to my agnosticism and think through the whole matter…I walked, prayed, and thought through what the Scriptures taught as well as reviewing my own reasons for being a Christian…Gradually the sun came out and the song came…This was and is the real basis of L’Abri. Teaching the historic Christian answers and giving honest answers to honest questions are crucial, but it was out of these struggles that the reality came, without which an incisive work like L’Abri would not have been possible” (Francis Schaeffer, True Spirituality, Preface.)  

After L’Abri was begun, a dispute erupted between Francis and his wife about whether Francis should go on the lecture circuit. “I have the answers. I know I have the answers,” Francis exclaimed, pounding the wall. A person can possess the truth and yet be uncertain; a person is rendered certain when he is possessed by the truth. The Holy Spirit has a central role in this. He can and sometimes does, drop truth on the soul like a snowflake on the nose when we do not expect it to come down. But usually he fixes truth by leading into temptation, which trial prompts prayer, thought, and hard work. Doubts must be dealt with. And it takes a big man, especially after having been a minister, to acknowledge the need to reexamine his belief system. The point must be arrived at, where, like Spurgeon and Schaeffer, we know that our Confession is right. Can we say, concerning our worldview, that we are so certain of its truth that we must not only speak for it and stand for it, but suffer for it if it comes to that? I do not speak only of basic truths like the existence of God and the recent historicity of creation, or even of  justification by faith and redemption by blood, but also those truths that are associate to what we believe in the main—those truths that mark us out as belonging to this or that dogmatic camp. It is not mere theism that God calls Christians to accept and convey. Neither is it mere Christianity. The doctrines of unconditional election and irresistible grace, for example, are essential to an acceptable understanding of the plan of salvation. Falsehoods concerning the doctrines of election and grace are numerous and nuanced. We need the help of a good Confession to sort our doctrines out and to get them right. The Westminster Assembly met, of course, in the Puritan age. The Westminster documents are the work of theologians of that epoch. What often impresses me when I read biographies of these saints is how disinterested they were concerning their sermons or treatises being published. Sermons were for preaching before congregations. A treatise or tractate was often no more than a personal attempt to clarify a doctrine, or it was an answer to an objection, or it was a rebuttal of a heresy, as in John Bunyan’s Reprobation Asserted, the full title of which continues like so: The Doctrine of Eternal Election and Reprobation Promiscuously Handled, in Eleven Chapters; and the subtitle of which runs like so: Wherein the Most Material Objections Made by the Opposers of this Doctrine, are Fully Answered; Several Doubts Removed, and Sundry Cases of Conscience Resolved. There was no mass market for books in that day. These men were not motivated by anything but learning aright and convincing their few correspondents of the truth, and glorifying God thereby. The typical Puritan writer, as learned and brilliant as he was, was content to let God order the outcome of his labors and to preserve some writings if he willed. We should not be surprised when a selfless, trusting person like that has the answers that we need. The Puritan had confidence that his beliefs were true; and because his beliefs were centered in the character of God as he is revealed in the Bible, his confidence was settled. 

To be separate from uncertainty concerning our beliefs yields relief, peace, and joy, but also strength, focus, and determination. We know that this has happened when we perceive that the weight of truth has settled into us. I liken this aplomb to the appearance and gait of a rhinoceros. Winds of false doctrine should no more unsettle our beliefs than a zephyr could topple that noble beast. The weight of his gut roots him to the ground; the weight of truth should hold us fast. We should become as immovable in our beliefs as a rhino cannot be pushed aside. Like the rhino, when we run, it should be straight forward, not left, not right, but straight on through as if nothing can stand in our way. This is what having conviction is like—there is no uncertainty. This is how truth is carried when it has landed to the bottom. It is a profound mobility. While others are getting blown over by each wind of doctrine, we should be slicing through the same contrary winds with truth, and with the dignified air of a rhino. When a rhino stands, you can’t move him; when he moves, you can’t stop him. If a Christian is like that, he will get something done for sure.


Friday, 30 January 2026

PART I, ARTICLE V: THE HOLY USE OF A CONFESSION OF FAITH, SECTION III

Moving on, now, from the doctrine of election, to that of sovereignty particularly. The order still is: Misters Taylor, McClurkin, and Mackay (X); Scripture (Y); The Westminster Confession of Faith (Z.)  

(X) “Calvin exalts the sovereignty of God, and this is right, but he errs in placing his root-idea of God in sovereign will rather than in love. Love is subordinated to sovereignty, instead of sovereignty to love.”

(Y) “The LORD hath made all for himself: yea, even the wicked for the day of evil” (Proverbs 16.4.) “Therefore hath he mercy on whom he will, and whom he will he hardeneth…Hath not the potter power over the clay, of the same lump to make one vessel unto honour, and another unto dishonour?” (Romans 9.18, 21.)

(Z) “God, from all eternity, did, by the most wise and holy counsel of his own will, freely, and unchangeably ordain whatsoever comes to pass…By the decree of God, for the manifestation of his glory, some men and angels are predestinated unto everlasting life, and others foreordained to everlasting death.”

Again, obviously and glaringly, as well as embarrassingly and shamefully, Misters X are all alone (with Dr. James Orr, whose inversion it is they chose for support), while Scripture and the Confession are close enough to kiss each other. If God makes everything for himself, ‘even the wicked for the day of evil,’ is love not subordinated to sovereignty, as Scripture, Calvin, and the Confession teach? And is this idea not reiterated in Romans 9 where it says that God ‘hath mercy on whom he will’? If the root-idea of God is love, would the Bible not say that God has mercy on all, or at least on whomever his love compels him to have mercy on? God is not just love; he is also holy, eternal, omnipresent, and omniscient. Are these not ‘root-ideas’? But as far as actions are concerned, the root-idea of God is his will, which is another way of saying, his sovereignty, or his sovereign will. To be sovereign is to have the right and power to do what you will. Indiscriminate love is not the deciding factor in who gets saved; discriminating will, is. If God chooses from eternity to have mercy, as Scripture teaches, then a sovereign choice lies behind his love, even if the Bible says that ‘God is love.’ If he chooses not to extend saving love, as Scripture also teaches, then a sovereign choice governs, and even rules over, his mercy. Sovereignty is never subordinate to love, grace, or mercy. Mercy may rejoice against judgment when the elect are saved by grace and gathered in; but sovereignty has already ruled over all. Someone might say, How is the Lord ‘not willing that any should perish,’ then? (2 Peter 3.9.) The answer is that we accept the statement, as we do all others in the Bible, on the authority of the Bible. We accept it, rejoice in it, and preach it, along with sovereignty. It may be, though, that only elect Christians are referred to in that verse, for it says there that the Lord is ‘longsuffering to us-ward’; that is, to the persons being addressed in the letter. If the whole world is alluded to by the statement, that is to say, every single sinner (which is doubtful considering the context), we leave the problem in the secret counsel of God’s will where it belongs. The word of God is clear, regardless, that God wills whatever will cause him the most glory; thus, he wills to meet out mercy to this person and not to that person. Is this an offensive thought? “What if God, willing to shew wrath, and to make his power known, endured with much longsuffering the vessels of wrath fitted to destruction” (Romans 9.22.) If God wills that no one perish, this will, or desire, does not override the fact that God wills to glorify himself through the manifestation of his wrath. That might not be a soothing thought. But the word of God is abrasive sometimes; it is not all balm. He accomplishes the glorification of himself by a demonstration of his fearsome holiness; and he accomplishes this through a sovereign choice from eternity to predestinate negatively as well as positively. Moreover, God is patient toward vessels of wrath—those who are fitted for ultimate destruction, “that he might make known the riches of his glory on the vessels of mercy, which he had afore prepared unto glory” (verse 23.) Why be ashamed or embarrassed by the fact that God will show the magnificence of his mercy by contrasting it with the fearsomeness of his wrath?  The following phrase from the Confession, ‘foreordained to everlasting death,’ is not objectionable. God has the right to do it, and he does it in order to magnify his attributes, which is to say, in order to glorify himself. So if love, not sovereignty, is at the bottom of who God is, it is self-directing love: love among the members of the Trinity. His love and his will are consistent with each other. What we know for sure—because we know it explicitly from Scripture—is that where love toward creatures is concerned, sovereign will lies at the bottom. If a shepherd has two herds of sheep running blindly toward a cliff, and he has decided beforehand to divert one herd but not the other, that is his right. Having chosen to divert one herd alone, he has ordained both: each to a different end. Whether God’s decree is active or passive, it is a decree nonetheless. That some souls are ‘foreordained to everlasting death’ may not be a pleasant thought. But this death is via guilt for sin. God punishes the guilty. It sounds good that God is bound to will mercy and that mercy must govern every decision that he makes. It is a consoling assumption. It reassures the idolatrous tendency in our sinful selves. We want the potter to have merciful power over the clay, and this is good. But if we would take away his right to withhold mercy if we could, this is evil. It is best to let God be God, lest we find ourselves on the wrong end of his power for not consenting to his word. God does not have mercy on sinners because he has to, because we want him to, or even because of faith, but because he wills to—sovereignty is the cause of mercy. Sovereign will is like an inscrutably directed river from parts unknown. Mercy comes down the river. Who gets to drink mercy from the river depends on who has been determined to be in the way as mercy winds its way through history. Or, it depends on who is made thirsty to drink. “And let him that is athirst come” (Revelation 22.17.) We would like to decide the question of mercy. We would choose it for both our sons. But what did Isaac do? His choice was caught in the stream of what God had chosen, for what is written? “And Isaac answered and said unto Esau, behold, I have made him [Jacob] thy lord” (Genesis 27.37.) Isaac’s unintended choice in time ends up being God’s discriminating choice from eternity, for what choice did God make? He chose one, not both; Jacob, but not Esau. “Jacob have I loved, but Esau have I hated” (Romans 9.13.) The odds are that if you pick up a modern commentary, maybe even an old one, and turn to the page dealing with this verse, you will find its meaning diminished. If the verse will be explained away, so must that part of Malachi 1 from where the statement comes. How much of the Bible must we be cunningly crafty with before we get the god that our flesh would rather have? Do we believe that unbelievers will come to faith if we can show them how nice God is? Is our faith in God that weak? Can’t we trust God to save whomever he has decided to set his mercy on? God does not want to appear nice. If he did, Romans 9 would be a romance instead of a revelation, Jacob and Esau would be identical twins on equal footing, and Pharaoh’s heart would have been softened. Romans chapter 9 is true to life. There are Jacobs and Esaus in our families, and sometimes a Pharaoh. No one can comprehend the divine, eternal will, and why one person is chosen to a good end while the other is not. God’s love for his creatures is not the arbiter of his decrees; if it were, his decrees would end in happiness for every one of his creatures, even the fallen angels; a sovereign God could make that happen. The kind of God that we want, and the kind of God that we find most agreeable, is not the kind of God that we have. The God of the Bible is a sovereign, holy, just, loving God who does what he pleases with what he has created. A Confession will protect us from creating a god in our image instead. It will protect us from views that are designed to cushion the Almighty blow of who God really is. And after we have accepted what the word of God teaches about God, we are on our way to becoming more comfortable with that than we were formerly comfortable with falsehoods and lies.   

The notion that love determines what God will do is a denigration of his power, for if God wills to be merciful to all, yet all will not receive his mercy, then God is powerless to overcome his own creatures—powerless to regenerate or even soften hearts. Therefore, in that case, it must be man, and man alone, who decides to populate God’s kingdom. God’s mercy goes out as an uncertain offer, then. Some resist; some don’t; all can. God has no say in it. But the Scripture assures us that that is all wrong, for ‘who hath resisted his will?’ (Romans 9.19.) The Confession is true to that: “God, the great Creator of all things, doth uphold, direct, dispose, and govern all creatures, actions, and things, from the greatest even to the least.” Love over sovereignty means that God is so controlled by that one attribute that he can do no other but what we wish him to do. And if God is powerless to save everyone, why should we believe that he has power to judge anyone? If sinners can resist his grace, why can’t guilty parties defy his judgment? How can his will be powerless one way (to save every sinner) and powerful in another (to judge every rebel?) Can he have power one way but not the other? Can he be like that and still be God? If he can’t put everyone into heaven, neither can he consign anyone to hell. But the Bible is clear that many sinners do go to hell, and that multitudes are in hell already. If we are not content with God’s will as it is written in Scripture, we end up with a God who might save, can’t judge, and does not rule. He does not know (for he has never determined it) who will be saved and how many.  We avoid inevitable reductions of divinity by coming to terms with a Confession of Faith. Love over sovereignty is a slippery slope that can take us over many a precipice. We need a good Confession.

That is a dire sign of how backslidden Christendom is, and of how thoughtless and man-centered our churches are, when the sovereignty of God is no longer regarded as the preeminent characteristic of God’s person. Men think to have been so kind by raising his love to such a degree that even God’s sovereign will hangs from it; but the switch has changed our faultless Creator from being and doing what his word says he is and does, to being characterized by the desires, decisions, and whims of his sinful creatures. If God’s will is subordinate to any attribute, he is not sovereign. If sovereignty exists, it must, by definition, overtop all. ‘Therefore hath he mercy on whom he will’ cannot be unless the sovereignty of God decides the matter. The statement means that he extends mercy according to his will; it does not mean that he must be mercifully willing. The crowning jewel of The Westminster Confession is how God is correctly and respectfully represented. He is absolutely sovereign, and man is entirely responsible, no matter if God has chosen or not, to have mercy on impotent man. The Assembly of the Westminster Confession was right to allow the full weight of both Sovereignty and Responsibility, without trying to solve the mystery. The Sacred is left alone when finite man is told to abstain from things too wonderful. That is meeker than trying to peer into a secret book that even angels do not get to open. That is more humble than attempting to explain something that an apostle passed over in silence, wiser than trying to unravel a scroll that an archangel wouldn’t dare touch, safer than jamming a puzzle together that only God is qualified to assemble. That vain effort of ours to figure out what we are told to leave alone leads to our running down one line of truth for the sake of another, by which unholy act we distort both, resulting in a quarrel with the LORD of hosts that will be settled on Judgment Day. “The doctrine of this high mystery of predestination is to be handled with special prudence and care,” the Confession says. An author should be especially watchful and reserved wherever great men have confessed great difficulty. When Solomon wrote that a threefold cord is not quickly broken, he was not prophesying of Taylor, McClurkin, and Mackay, apparently. Their flimsy cord is quickly broken by the holy use of a Confession of Faith. By their anxiety to answer the unanswerable—by their attempt to unravel a sealed scroll—they end up face to face against  Almighty God for erasing his election from ‘before the foundation of the world.’ They end up asserting that God’s will must be to have mercy on all, when the Bible so clearly tells us that he will have mercy on whomever he wills, or has willed, to have mercy on. Mr. Mackay says this in his conclusion: “For many years now, I have sought to shepherd the flock of God, and in my pastoral ministry I have stood with hundreds of individuals and families in ‘the valley of the shadow’ as they have reeled in grief and bewilderment under the blows of stunning adversity and bereavement. I could not, and I did not, tell them that this inexplicable sorrow, this ghastly tragedy, this sudden bereavement, had been decreed in Eternity past by their loving, Heavenly Father.” That would have been safer to do, though—safer than having to stand before God one Day to explain to him why sinners were solaced at the expense of the Will, Nature, and Providence of God! By thinking to be able to fathom the unfathomable—by approaching the unapproachable to try and solve the unsolvable—these three men have traded the ‘high mystery’ of God’s decrees for an irrational view that evacuates the essential meanings of sovereignty, predestination, and election. Isaiah would say that they ‘have eaten up the vineyard’ (3.14.) Their view is as irreverent as it is irrational, for if God loves all men alike, he must be powerless to save them all, since multitudes end up in hell; and if he is powerless to save everyone he loves, he must be powerless to judge the wicked, which means that sinners cannot and will not be held responsible for their evil deeds. That God favors the elect with a predestined love is the only way out of this heap of heresies. Let’s hear Jesus Christ preach it: “I pray for them: I pray not for the world, but for them which thou hast given me; for they are thine” (John 17.9.) Jesus Christ discriminates in favor of the elect; he will also judge all sinners who have not been given to him: those who are not foreordained to life everlasting. Where does Calvinism spring from except Jesus Christ? 

In light of the significance of what must be rewritten after extenuating the subject matter of Romans 9, should we not warn that there might be hell to pay for trying to untwist knots that God has chosen to leave tied up? Discreet preachers are content to work on either side of the knot, and to preach the full force of each disclosure and leave the problem alone. But along come these wise-guys who must think they are more informed than an apostle! They will explain away the paradoxical by effacing doctrines! And they will rail at someone like Calvin, misrepresent him, and discourage everyone they can from reading his godly books! For the welfare of our souls, we would be wise to trade the tiny teachers of the 20th century for the masters of bygone ages, and let a blasphemous book like Biblical Balance on Election & Free Will politely slip from our fingers and into a garbage can. We need a Confession of Faith for our protection—and should read the works of men who drew the Westminster Confession up, books by William Bridge, Thomas Goodwin, and Jeremiah Burroughs. By this we may avoid being cheated of our inheritance: the august doctrines of the Bible by which we may get to know what God is truly like and what he really does. That is a marvelous thing to meditate on: why God wills to have mercy on this person and not that person, from a decision made in eternity, without basing his decision on anything that will take place in the world. It is a marvelous thing to think about and to get lost in the reflection of—if we accept it. If we do not accept it, some of the most awesome truths of revelation are just a vexation to us, and we are left tormented with wanting God Almighty to be someone that he is not. Humble men do not demand answers after God interjects with, “Who art thou that repliest against God?”  And they are blessed by glorying in the fact that God is sovereign to do as he pleases with his creatures. The men of the Confession were not only able, but able because they were abased.

There are some marvels of divinity that we have no business knowing. The secret that connects man’s responsibility with God’s predestination is only one of many that are none of our business. When ‘caught up into paradise,’ the apostle Paul ‘heard unspeakable words, which it is not lawful for a man to utter’ (2 Corinthians 12.4.) The apostle John, at the ready to write what the seven thunders uttered, was told to ‘write them not’ (Revelation 10.4.) The KING OF KINGS AND LORD OF LORDS has a name known only to himself (Revelation 19.12.) Persons who insist on an answer as to how God can find fault with souls who have no predestined mercy are dealt with right in the passage where both man’s responsibility and the sovereignty of God are asserted. They stupidly put themselves in the crosshairs of God’s lecture: “Nay but, O man, who art thou that repliest against God? Shall the thing formed say to him that formed it, why hast thou made me thus?” (Romans 9.20.)

It is essential to follow a Confession of Faith because errors are popular in our churches and because we are not as wise as we think we are to detect them. As Patrick Simpson informed parliament in 1606: “Remember, that spiritual darkness, flowing from a very small beginning, doth insinuate and thrust itself into the house of God, as men can hardly discern by what secret means the light was dimmed, and darkness creeping in, got the upper hand; and in the end, at unawares, all was involved in a misty cloud of horrible apostacy” (John Howie, The Scots Worthies, p 105.) We need a Confession of Faith for our helper. Indeed, why not use more than one? I mostly recommend The Westminster triad, The Belgic Confession, The Heidelberg Catechism, and The Canons of Dort. I use these the most; and I would be willing to swear, under oath, that God, in a remarkable way, led me, seemingly against my will, to use those few in particular. These Confessions contain no major differences of opinion among them. For the sake of accuracy on major doctrines like the person of the Lord and election, an emphasis on a lesser matter like the baptism of infants can be tolerated. By the use of a reliable Confession, we will find, moreover, with the passage of time, that some things that we once hated have become precious and that some things that once irked us we now barely disagree with. Some of us will always take issue with the baptism of infants—and we should—but we should not overreact any more than Spurgeon did. The Prince of Preachers got believer-baptized as a teenager, against the wishes of his father; but he was wise to retain his respect for the Westminster triad, even to the point of placing a copy of the Westminster Shorter Catechism under the foundation stone of his church years later. If it was not this Catechism, it was the Baptist Confession of Faith from 1689, which is essentially the same. He did not throw the whole away for the sake of one minor irritant. About the Westminster Shorter Catechism, he said this in a speech before the General Assembly of the Free Church of Scotland in 1866: 

“We have a sort of catechetical seminary connected with our church, in which we teach a little book that is known by you all, your Shorter Catechism with Proofs, in which, of course, I have made a slight alteration in regard to baptism. Now, the fashion across the border is to laugh at this book, and say it is out of date, and so on. Well, I should like to see someone write a better summary of Scripture doctrine. Until somebody gives us a better book, we’ll stick to it” (C. H. Spurgeon, Speeches at Home and Abroad, p. 60.) 

We have wandered away from the compendiums of our Christian Faith. Pastors, with good intention, but on the basis of indoctrination and/or because of prejudice, dismiss them, and tell their brethren that they all should get back to the Bible instead. In spite of such remarks, though, pastors read the Bible alongside poorly executed theses from modern book stores, incorporating into their system a variety of opinions that are unbiblical and heretical; then these harmful ideas are propagated in the sermons they deliver. It is discouraging and humiliating to think that our favorite contemporary authors are so often weak and wrong when compared with scholars in divinity of centuries ago. But the Christian who cares enough to look into it will see that this is the case. A Christian author who is both dependable and alive is an endangered species.


Thursday, 29 January 2026

PART I, ARTICLE V: THE HOLY USE OF A CONFESSION OF FAITH, SECTION II

Separation from Error 

A Confession of Faith is a summary of God’s most vital truth to man. It deflects major falsehoods, be they straightforward or sophisticated. A falsehood that I was burdened to separate from some time ago, which I did with help from a Confession or two, is a major one. The inevitable concessions that follow from that falsehood are surprisingly serious. These concessions follow from trying to reconcile the irreconcilable—a foolish endeavor that was attempted by three men whose anxiety about what the Bible says overcame their reverence for God. The following verses contain the two lines of truth that they undertook to harmonize:

“Therefore hath he mercy on whom he will, and whom he will he hardeneth. Thou wilt say then unto me, why doth he yet find fault? For who hath resisted his will? Nay but, O man, who art thou that repliest against God? Shall the thing formed say to him that formed it, why hast thou made me thus? Hath not the potter power over the clay, of the same lump to make one vessel unto honour, and another unto dishonour?” (Romans 9. 18-21.)

The two pillars alluded to here are the Sovereignty of God and the Responsibility of Man. Both are true to the fullest extent that can be derived from what it means to be sovereign and responsible. God is totally sovereign. Man is utterly responsible. God hardens a man’s heart. But he still finds fault with this man for not repenting. Sovereignty is a word that we use to describe the right and exercise of supreme authority. We have that in, “Therefore hath he mercy on whom he will.” Man’s reply is the problem, “Why doth he yet find fault?” And the answer to this impetuous objection is the rhetorical question, “O man, who art thou that repliest against God?” In other words, “Never mind, for God does as he pleases.” There is no reply allowed in the face of what God does. And therefore man is simply responsible to God, even if God has not chosen him to a merciful end. Man’s mouth should be stopped right here, as it will certainly be on Judgment Day. That God is sovereign is the only answer to, “Why doth he yet find fault?” There is no conflict or friction between Sovereignty and Responsibility unless we ask that question. “Why doth he yet find fault?” Since God has mercy on whomever he chooses to have mercy on, why does he yet find fault with persons he has not chosen to be merciful toward? Try to settle that question (with some other answer than ‘God is Sovereign’) in order to satisfy your overcurious mind, and you will distort the doctrines of Sovereignty and Responsibility both. You will have to undervalue one line of truth in your effort to bring the two together; and while you are busy belittling the one, the other will become a monster behind your back. The temptation is to say that God is unfair and that man is not responsible to him, unless God chooses, or has chosen, to have mercy on all, and that it is the sinner’s prerogative to conform to, or else frustrate, the divine will by either believing or not believing. The revelation is that God is sovereign to not choose every person to a good end—to pass by a segment of sinners, whose destiny, determined from eternity, is everlasting misery. Who are we to question his sovereign decrees? God’s answer to our questioning is, “Nay, but O man, who art thou that repliest against God?” Before examining and criticizing the error of persisting against God’s answer concerning his right over his creatures, here is a brief commentary by C. H. Spurgeon on the issue in question:    

“The system of truth is not one straight line, but two. No man will ever get a right view of the gospel until he knows how to look at the two lines at once…Now, if I were to declare that man was so free to act, that there is no presidence of God over his actions, I should be driven very near to Atheism; and if, on the other hand, I declare that God so overrules all things, as that man is not free to be responsible, I am driven at once to Antinomianism or fatalism. That God predestinates, and that man is responsible, are two things that few can see. They are believed to be inconsistent and contradictory; but they are not…These two truths, I do not believe, can ever be welded into one upon any human anvil, but one they shall be in eternity: they are two lines that are so nearly parallel, that the mind that shall pursue them farthest, will never discover that they converge; but they do converge, and they will meet somewhere in eternity, close to the throne of God, whence all truth doth spring” (C. H. Spurgeon, Sovereign Grace and Man’s Responsibility.)

C. H. Spurgeon is an authority whose ministry was authenticated by the Holy Ghost. His judgment on a matter like this should not be taken lightly. He would have looked into it; he would have meditated on it; he would have prayed about it; and he often did preach and write about it. God chooses whom to have mercy on; but he finds fault with the souls that he has not chosen to a merciful end. The Bible’s answer to the apparent unfairness of that is to never mind: “Nay but, O man, who art thou that repliest against God? Shall the thing formed say to him that formed it, Why hast thou made me thus?” So man should leave the puzzle alone, and continue to preach: “Whosoever believeth in him shall receive remission of sins” (Acts 10.43.) It is not for us to find out why man is responsible to come to God even if he cannot—even if he’s not among the elect. We simply accept that man’s willingness to believe and repent depends on God’s choice: “And the Lord added to the church daily such as should be saved” (Acts 2.47.) In other words, God grants the increase (1 Corinthians 3.6.) But along come these minor scholars. Imagine their stubborn arrogance. They are going to appease the apparent contradiction between Sovereignty and Responsibility—something that the greatest theologians do not attempt, not even the apostle Paul, and they will do it in a booklet, in 63 small pages of script! Yet they are not ashamed to say, “This is a matter that cannot be approached in a spirit of nonchalance.” I may not be charged with doing the same in this article, for I am not attempting the impossible and forbidden, only exposing the folly of three men who tried. From the back cover, their objective is: 

“The authors of this book on Election and Free Will have attempted to find the balance between two lines of truth which may seem to be contradictory. Their desire is to help some believers who have been confused by too much emphasis on either” (Franklin Taylor, Harold Mackay, Robert McClurkin, Biblical Balance on Election & Free Will.) 

Election involves Sovereignty; the Will of man, whether free or not, involves Responsibility. These three men will transform the apparent clash existing between these concepts into a dovetail! Serious repercussions result from the indiscretion of trying to understand how God is sovereign to choose, while man is responsible to a God who does not choose him—how God can choose to withhold mercy, and how man must be responsible to repent anyway. The negative deductions could be easily avoided by simply resting satisfied in God being sovereign. I will line up some of what these men say in their less than precious booklet, and place the sayings beside my Westminster Confession in order to show what document agrees most with Scripture. First, I will line up statements about Election, and comment a little; then I will line up statements on Sovereignty in particular, and comment on that. The order will be: Misters Taylor, McClurkin, and Mackay (X); Scripture (Y); The Westminster Confession of Faith (Z.) 

(X) “Individuals are not in the church because they are elect. They are elect because they are in the Church…As each individual believer trusts Christ, he is put ‘into Christ’ and is therefore part of God’s elect…Take destiny out of the doctrine of election and most difficulties would fade away…Keep in mind then that election is ‘IN CHRIST.’ We are not among the elect until we come into Christ by repentance and faith.”

(Y) “Elect according to the foreknowledge of God the Father, through sanctification of the Spirit, unto obedience and sprinkling of the blood of Jesus Christ” (1 Peter 1.2.) “According as he hath chosen us in him before the foundation of the world” (Ephesians 1.4.) “God hath from the beginning chosen you to salvation” (2 Thessalonians 2.13.)

(Z) “Those of mankind that are predestinated unto life, God, before the foundation of the world was laid, according to his eternal and immutable purpose, and the secret counsel and good pleasure of his will, hath chosen in Christ, unto everlasting glory.”

‘Chosen’ and ‘elected’ are synonymous terms, which the three men denominated by the letter X, aver. Now compare what is said by X: ‘we are not among the elect until…repentance and faith’; compare this, I say, with what is said by Y?—: ‘chosen in him before the foundation of the world…from the beginning chosen to salvation.’ And then observe that the idea in Y is repeated by Z, almost word for word: ‘predestinated unto life…before the foundation of the world was laid.’ Yea, observe that ‘predestinated unto life’ is just another way of saying ‘chosen…before the foundation of the world’ (Ephesians 1.4.) From the full statement of X, it is obvious that by ‘we are not among the elect until’ is meant: not elect until faith, not elect until faith in Christ, not elect until we are in the Church. Scripture and the Confession (Y and Z) are in agreement against that. Y: ‘chosen…before the foundation of the world’; Z: ‘predestinated unto life…before the foundation of the world was laid.’ Whatever it means to be chosen ‘IN CHRIST’—whether by Christ, because of Christ, for Christ, or even ‘in Christ,’ we are bound to interpret that in light of the phrase, ‘before the foundation of the world.’ A decision was made, a choice, an election, ‘before the foundation of the world.’ Certain persons, the elect, were never outside of Christ in some sense. They were ‘in him [Christ] before the foundation of the world’ (Ephesians 1.4.) The elect were always elect in God’s mind, before they were born, before they were created—before they became members of the Church by repenting and believing. By ‘take destiny out of the doctrine of election,’ Misters X mean to erase election from eternity past and to make it to begin in time. By capitalizing ‘IN CHRIST,’ they mean to deemphasize the eternality of election, as if Jesus Christ has nothing to do with eternity. This is the ‘sleight of men’ and ‘cunning craftiness’ that we are warned of in Ephesians 4. By this move, they make faith the basis of election. Mr. McClurkin does that very plainly on page 30 of his booklet. If election is merely the result of faith, as they say, then that can be no election ‘before the foundation of the world,’ as the Bible says. We can be certain of this because faith happens in the world. Faith happens in the world; but election happens ‘before the foundation of the world.’ If destiny (by which is meant ‘eternality’) is taken out of election, it is impossible and untrue that God has chosen any person at all ‘before the foundation of the world,’ like the Scripture says. By trying to put something together that God has warned to leave apart—by trying to reconcile the seeming disharmony between the doctrines of Sovereignty and Responsibility, these men wind up squared off against the word of God and God himself. Why did they handle the doctrine of election like this? They handled it like this because they believe that God is guilty if he has determined ‘before the foundation of the world’ to have mercy on certain persons but not others. They put election after faith in order to avoid the fact that God’s election is an eternal choice to have mercy on a select portion of humanity. It must be God’s will to have mercy on all—that is their doctrine, which is contrary to, ‘hath he mercy on whom he will,’ (Romans 9.18), which statement implies that it is God’s will to have mercy on select persons before the actual mercy is granted in the world. God must have elected it so to be, only for some, before faith; this is the truth. 

The answer to, “Why doth he yet find fault?” (Romans 9.19) is, “O man, who art thou that repliest against God” (verse 20.) These men will not accept that, but persist with, “Why doth he yet find fault?” Their sinful persistence is the reason their booklet was written. They stand in for the hypothetical stubborn man of that verse; they personify him. On page 40, Mr. McClurkin says, “Pharaoh hardened his own heart first before it is said that God hardened his heart.” But then he contradicts himself further down when he says, “Hardness follows when God withholds his softening grace.” If hardness ‘follows’ the withholding of grace, how could Pharaoh have hardened his heart ‘first’? Any heart will harden, without effort, when God withholds grace. And a graceless heart is the definition of a hard heart, if anything is; that heart is hard which has not grace. Pharaoh had no grace. Therefore, his heart was hard already, was hardened by God’s continued withholding, and was hardened the more by Pharaoh’s disobedience. From eternity God purposed to withhold his mercy in the case of Pharaoh. “Even for this same purpose have I raised thee up,” says God, “that I might shew my power in thee” (Romans 9.17.) In other words, God raised him up in order to show his sovereign power and right over his creature by exercising wrath instead of mercy. The problem of how Pharaoh’s heart was hardened, if it is even a problem, is easily addressed by Stephen Charnock:

“If hardness follows upon God’s withholding his softening grace, it is not by any positive act of God, but from the natural hardness of man. If you put fire near to wax or rosin, both will melt; but when that fire is removed, they return to their natural quality of hardness and brittleness; the positive act of the fire is to melt and soften, and the softness of the rosin is to be ascribed to that; but the hardness is from the rosin itself, wherein the fire hath no influence, but only a negative act by a removal of it: so, when God hardens a man, he only leaves him to that stony heart which he derived from Adam, and brought with him into the world” (Stephen Charnock, The Existence and Attributes of God.)

The reason the three amigos give for taking up their fool’s errand is to save the preaching ministry. They suppose that while the two concepts of Sovereignty and Responsibility remain apparently discrepant there can be no motive to preach. They are stuck on that question, “Why doth he yet find fault with sinners that he wills not to have mercy on?” In their booklet (though not in so many words) they repeatedly ask this question. That is what they do by trying to force these two lines of truth into visible harmony. They ask, “Why doth he yet find fault?” Then they force an answer—an answer that is more satisfying to them than the assertion that God is sovereign to make vessels according to his will, whether unto honor or dishonor. They need an answer, you see, because if the question of whether or not there will be mercy for a sinner depends on God having chosen him or not, this means, to them, that God is unfair, and that the sinner can’t be held responsible. “It takes away the guilt of sin,” they say, “and lifts the blame of hell from the souls of men and lays it at the feet of God.” (And therefore we can’t preach anymore.) The answer, “O man, who art thou that repliest against God?”—in other words, the sovereign God will do as he pleases—that is not good enough for this trio. Their desire that Scripture be more palatable is the very attitude that is reproved in Romans 9. Their attempt to come up with another answer than the one that is given is rebellion. And their booklet is the teaching of rebellion against the LORD, even though it may be unintentionally done. The same thing that the prophet Jeremiah said to Hananiah should be said to them: “The LORD hath not sent thee; but thou makest this people to trust in a lie” (Jeremiah 28.15.) These men want a different answer than ‘who art thou that repliest against God?’—even if it means that they must bend the Scriptures to their will. They do not like man to be dependent on God’s choice to show mercy or not.  It must be man who must choose the merciful God because if it is God’s choice to save some persons and not others, God is guilty and man is blameless. This is their view. It is not a biblical view, but a psychological complaint. Their scheme is blasphemous in that it cannot be executed without canceling out glorious doctrines such as predestination, election, and even sovereignty. The lesser sin is that Calvinism must be misrepresented in the process, and stated as ‘a theology which totally eliminates human choice.’ They call men who believe like Spurgeon on this issue ‘extreme Calvinists’ and ‘hyper-Calvinists,’ and count on the reader being too ignorant to know better. They pretend that Calvinism imputes guilt to God, then say, “Did God cause sin? No!” They further pretend that Calvinists offer the gospel only to select people, then say, “This gospel message excluded no one.” They pretend that Calvinists do not believe the Sacrifice of Christ is of infinite worth, and that Calvinism ‘robs humanity of all morality and all responsibility.’ They state that Calvin’s doctrine ‘is an absolute perversion of the Scriptural teaching regarding predestination.’ Anyone acquainted with Calvinism knows that every one of these accusations is false. God is sovereign and just; man is responsible and guilty; the gospel should be extended to all; the sacrifice of Christ is sufficient to cleanse every sin that has ever been committed; and predestination is accepted according to Scripture—that is Calvinism. It is not hyper, extreme, or profane; it is not a perversion of Scripture, but an honest exposition of what the richest pockets of revelation contain. Without a Confession to turn to, it is easy to be deceived by pseudo-scholars, which deception may cause us to be too proud to accept who God is, and then coerced into becoming as slanderous as these three men are toward some of the most honorable names in the history of Christendom. These angry, spiteful writers turn the better men that they disagree with into wild-eyed extremists; and the uneducated members of churches who are given their material will believe that they have done well to defend the holy, the good, and the true. The doctrines of God are transfigured into the teachings of man, and readers will not even notice. The slander in this booklet would be hard to rebut without a historical knowledge of theology. Without such knowledge, the reader will not know that the authors of it slant and spin the works of those they dislike, and his guard would be down. Once it is known, however, that they falsify the religious beliefs of others, a righteous rage is born. Competent scholars do not have to lie and defame in order to defend truth and to convince people to believe what is right. Most of our righteous indignation, though, should come from noticing that these Christian men do not like who God is.

Acts 4.27, 28: “For of a truth against thy holy child Jesus, whom thou hast anointed, both Herod, and Pontius Pilate, with the Gentiles, and the people of Israel, were gathered together, for to do whatsoever thy hand and thy counsel determined before to be done.” The predetermining counsel of God in choosing Christ to suffer is here put side by side with responsibility on the part of the persons who put Jesus to death. God’s predetermination, even for the greatest evil deed in the history of the world to be done, does not negate responsibility in them who did the evil deed. We know this because the persons who crucified Jesus, their deed having been determined beforehand by God to be done, are stated as having done it ‘by wicked hands’ (Acts 2.23.) Since God predetermined the death of his only begotten Son, for which deed men are nevertheless held responsible, why question the responsibility of sinners on the ground that God, from eternity, has not chosen them for salvation? God’s choice from eternity, whether for Jesus to be crucified, or for mercy to be withheld from certain sinners, involves responsibility on both counts: as pertains to Jesus’ murderers, and as pertains to hardened sinners. The doctrine of a discriminate election from eternity does not, as misters Taylor, McClurkin, and Mackay allege, “take away the guilt of sin and lift the blame of hell from the souls of men and lay it at the feet of God.” It does not take away guilt for sin or lay blame on God any more than Jesus’ crucifers are cleared of guilt or any more than God can be held guilty for predetermining that his only begotten Son be crucified.      

It is idolatry to make the infinite God into an image that our finite minds can be at ease with. It is wickedness to limit the sovereign God to what we believe ‘God is love’ means. ‘I am that I am’ will do what he will. Would it not be more honorable to reject him than to convince men that he is different from what his word says he is? “It will not be denied that God has commanded mankind not to kill. Yet, in putting our Saviour to death, the Jews did no more than God had determined, before, should be done. He determined, therefore, that his law should be broken” (Josiah Hopkins, The Doctrine of Decrees Essential to the Divine Character.) Are we going to blame God? Or will we accept who he is and what he does? The answers to some questions are as forbidden to us as ‘the fruit of the tree…in the midst of the garden’ (Genesis 3.3) was forbidden to Adam and Eve. “Whence it strictly follows that if these questioners could be gratified by giving them a religion without a mystery, verily they ‘should be as gods’” (R. L. Dabney, Discussions, Volume 3, p. 347.)


Wednesday, 28 January 2026

PART I, ARTICLE V: THE HOLY USE OF A CONFESSION OF FAITH, SECTION I


Even a man who is both holy and good can, because of undue trust in a denomination, lead us astray in a capital matter. This happened to me through my spiritual mentor by the use of a Brethren pamphlet that he gave me to read. Thankfully, the false teachings in this pamphlet were soon overruled by Creeds that the Holy Spirit conspicuously led me to adopt for my protection. 

“God is a Spirit: and they that worship him must worship him in spirit and in truth” (John. 4.24.)

To be holy has much to do with being separate—set apart from what is untrue and impure. As God is far removed from sin and error of every kind, he would have his worshippers abstain from the same, and to worship him in spirit and in truth. A pure God can be pleased only by what is pure. He who is Spirit must be approached in the right spirit. He who is truth is adored only through truth. To bring purity of spirit to the worship of a pure Spirit is the obvious necessity and aim in religious exercise; and this purity of spirit is either more or less, depending on our knowledge and acceptance of who God really is and what God really does. The affections are drawn to God through the mind. The more the mind has a right view of God, the more purely the affections may ascend to him, though for solemn reasons God may withdraw from persons who apprehend him most properly, as, for a season, he did from Job. We are stimulated to worship God by apprehending the character of his person and the workings of his providence. If we misunderstand truth, we think falsely of God, since truth is about God, and God is truth. 

Our worship is graciously accepted through faith in Jesus Christ; we worship the Father through the Son, whose righteousness is ours through this faith. Salvation is worked into us by the Holy Ghost in regeneration; this begins our sanctification, or progress in our faith. Then we are called to ‘work salvation out with fear and trembling’ (Philippians 2.12.) In other words, the Christian who is sanctified by God by being renewed in regeneration must then sanctify himself by progressive obedience. To make progress in obedience, we must learn what to obey and who this God is to whom we owe obedience. So, is our worship as sanctified as it could be when we think that God is such a person that he is not, or when we suppose that God did this or that when he didn’t? Our worship then is mixed with lies about God. We tell people that he is this way when he isn’t, and that he does this and that when he doesn’t. More than anything else, we need to be right about the character of God. We need wisdom and understanding in proportion to the zeal with which they should be sought: “Get wisdom, get understanding: forget it not; neither decline from the words of my mouth” (Proverbs 4.5.) Communion between us and God is undermined by untruth. It is the same between all partners in relationship. Cold religion comes by thinking that God is who he is not, and that he does what he does not. He will draw closer when we impute to him no lies. 

“But the hour cometh, and now is, when the true worshippers shall worship the Father in spirit and in truth: for the Father seeketh such to worship him” (John 4.23.) The hour for true worship has come, Jesus says. It ‘now is.’ If it could be said to be ‘now is’ in Jesus’ day, how much more in ours, twenty centuries later? Has the hour for true worship come for us personally? Are we enjoying this hour? The Father wants true worshippers. He wants us to worship him ‘in spirit and in truth.’

But why bring a Confession of Faith into this, and have that come between us and God, and between us and God’s truth, the Bible? Why not go straight to the Bible to know God, and never mind other avenues? This objection is more often emotional than thoughtful, and is a popular one among Dispensationalists and Fundamentalists; that is, among most pastors and Christian writers of the 20th century. There is nothing wrong with a passion for the infallible truth and nothing but. A person might do well who reads only his Bible. William Tiptaft (b. 1803) did that: “His studie was on litel but the Bible” (J. H. Philpot, The Seceders, p. 15.) William Tiptaft is piously remembered for having lived on this unmixed diet, notwithstanding that his partner in secession from the Church of England, J. C. Philpot, is probably more piously remembered, though he imbibed a little theology on the side. I have no doubt that a Christian with just his Bible, if he will be led by the Spirit in humble submission to his Lord, should do as much good as anyone, and be more holy than the average pastor or seminary professor. But a Christian typically attends church. And what church has no ‘Statement of Faith,’ which is nothing else than a term for ‘Confession of Faith’ or ‘Creed.’ And where is the Christian who reads only his Bible? And who can or should, neglect Christian history? If, in addition to reading the Bible, a Christian reads religious books, or if he listens to the sermons of his pastor, this extracurricular material, whether he has subscribed to it or not, is, to some degree, his Confession of Faith. We adopt the opinions and interpretations of others, almost without our notice or consent. The adoption of a Confession will offset and override what we unwittingly absorb. If what we read or hear does not come through men who are tethered to a good Confession, we are likely being led astray. Writers of Confessions were well-instructed scholars, even masters in the word of God. They were learned men; they were good men; they were praying men; they were holy men. Their works are what the Bible would call ‘bulwarks’: defensive structures built to resist assaults. 

What follows from the use of a Confession for self-defense is circumspection. To be circumspect is ‘to be watchful on all sides’; this exercise is for the purpose of standing fast against winds of false doctrine. Circumspection leads to confidence concerning one’s beliefs; this, in turn, leads to ability and positive influence. Christians who are remembered for the impact that they have had, were usually catechized through the use of a Confession. They were effective Christians because they were circumspect and confident, which fitness had much to do with the Confession that they were catechized with. To worship in spirit and in truth, contrary winds need to be withstood. There is a biblical warrant for the use of a Confession. Here it is:

“And he gave some, apostles; and some, prophets; and some, evangelists; and some, pastors and teachers; for the perfecting of the saints, for the work of the ministry, for the edifying of the body of Christ: till we all come in the unity of the faith, and of the knowledge of the Son of God, unto a perfect man, unto the measure of the stature of the fulness of Christ: that we henceforth be no more children, tossed to and fro, and carried about with every wind of doctrine, by the sleight of men, and cunning craftiness, whereby they lie in wait to deceive; but speaking the truth in love, may grow up into him in all things, which is the head, even Christ” (Ephesians 4.11-15.)

Apostles and prophets are not with us anymore. Most of us will be agreed on that. But evangelists, pastors, and teachers are still being given to the Church. They are still given, “for the perfecting of the saints…till we all come in the unity of the faith…that we henceforth be no more children…carried about with every wind of doctrine.” This is the object of a Confession of Faith—to grow us up in the unity of our faith and to separate us from error. We might even say that the object of a Confession is to grow us up in the unity of our faith by separating us from error, or, ‘for the establishing of consent touching true religion,’ which amounts to the same thing (William Cunningham, The Reformers and the Theology of the Reformation, p. 166.) And this is why teachers and pastors have composed these Confessions. It is always the business of church leaders and fathers of families to lead the effort toward unity of faith; and they would do well to use faithful, well-formulated Confessions to do it. As a Christian becomes acquainted with Protestant history, he cannot but recognize that the pastors of our day do not compare well for excellence beside the men who drew up the old Creeds, Catechisms, Canons, and Confessions. Such articles cannot be surpassed nor equaled for concise, correct theology, especially as they deal with doctrinal matters of the utmost gravity. Reliable Confessions of Faith require the precision and caution that can be executed only by Assemblies of the soberest heads and warmest hearts. Where one man is weak, another is strong, and the whole together form a vanguard and a rereward to defend what is most holy. Together they are bands of critics and judges, making sure that nothing indispensable is missed; that nothing secondary supersedes; that nothing superfluous is allowed; that no pet dogmas are trumpeted; and that falsehoods are marked, disproved, and then routed by properly interpreted Scripture proofs. All that we do as Christians should be to the purpose of securing and maintaining close communion with God. Whichever doctrines are indispensable to this connection between God and man, the Reformed Confessions are excellent on. If a Christian knows these truths and meditates on them, he will experience better relations with God by such knowledge and exercise than by all the new Bible-study workbooks together: those popular fads (like the Alpha course) that are continuously being pressed upon churches by enthusiastic, though ignorant, pastors. To get the understanding that Solomon recommends in Proverbs, we need to know what to reach for. By gathering with others to apprehend something of the essentials of our faith, a bond of love may happen that is sweeter than average Christian unity, just as John was loved by Jesus in a special way. And this is best accomplished through the use of our Bible, with a reliable Confession to assist. 

I come now to my intention in this article. Separation from—this is what I mean to emphasize as the way to holiness by the use of a Confession. There are three huge clogs to worship that a Confession may help to separate us from: Error, Uncertainty, and Inability. In the first head I aim to show how, by the use of a Confession, error is beaten down and cast aside.


Tuesday, 27 January 2026

PART I, ARTICLE IV: FOUR CIRCUMSTANCES AGAINST JOB, SECTION VI

Conclusion 

Tribulation begets perseverance; perseverance begets blessing. Job did not persevere in vain. It is better to persevere out of gratitude to God for grace received, not because we seek a reward. God will distribute treasures in heaven for works done in faith; and the greatest work of faith is to persevere in tribulation. What did it profit Job to persevere? One, his good character was improved, and he grew in his knowledge of the LORD.  Two, his request, as unusual as it was notable, was granted: “Oh that my words were now written!  oh that they were printed in a book!  That they were graven with an iron pen and lead in the rock for ever!” (Job 19.23, 24.) Now Job’s words are engraved forever as part of Holy Scripture. We should imitate Job, and ask as uncommonly and stupendously as he did. Three, the LORD accepted Job and set him up as a mediator for his three friends. After they were told to offer sacrifices to God, they were directed to reckon Job’s prayers as their means of mediation: “for him will I accept: lest I deal with you after your folly, in that ye have not spoken of me the thing which is right, like my servant Job” (42.8.)  It is hard to know whether the LORD was referring, by ‘the thing which is right,’ to Job’s confession, or to his confession and his lines of dialogue.  Due to Job’s confession, the LORD might have disregarded Job’s hard words that are found in the dialogue.  Regardless, Job’s role as intercessor at the end befits his sacrificial worship at the start. Job was a high priest outside and before, the institution of the Mosaic Law for Israel. He was singled out as blameless by God, chosen to suffer, tempted by the devil directly, obliged to defend his honor, ordained to intercede, and blessed in his latter end; and therefore it is difficult to resist the deduction that he is a type of Christ. Not many men are thus distinguished. And four, not only was Job completely restored, he was given double the measure of his lost fortune and as many children as he had lost.  Indeed, “the LORD gave Job twice as much as he had before…He had also seven sons and three daughters” (42.10, 13.) As if that were not enough, “In all the land were no women found so fair as the daughters of Job” (verse 15.) And Job “saw his sons, and his sons’ sons, even four generations” (verse 16.) We may assume that Job was physically restored as well. “So Job died, being old and full of days” (verse 17.) Is this not the happiest close to the story of a man’s life in all of literature? In getting a double portion of what he had lost, Job is a type of each and every saint. To become a good type is the best that a person can do for his fellow man. The ‘hundred and forty years’ (42.16) that were added to Job’s life amounts to a second life, and should remind us of life everlasting for those who persevere in faith until the end. “And I will restore to you the years that the locust hath eaten, the cankerworm, and the caterpillar, and the palmerworm, my great army which I sent among you” (Joel 2.25.) Job’s devouring insects were the Sabeans, wind and fire from the sky, and the Chaldeans: the army of Satan appointed by God. We all have insects appointed to our hurt, for our own good: an army assigned by God to vex us onward.  

Job was separated from his family, his belongings, and his popularity in order to separate him from the worst in himself. And this is the purpose of tribulation. As R. C. Trench points out in his Study of Words, the word ‘tribulation’ is derived from the Latin word, ‘tribulum,’ a thrashing instrument used to separate corn from husks. The book of Job might well be called, The Tribulation of Job or even The Thrashing of Job. “In the world ye shall have tribulation” (John 16.33.) In the world, we must undergo some thrashing.    

Like in the trying life of Job, our circumstances are overcome by perseverance in the LORD.  Perseverance is never in vain. “Therefore, my beloved brethren, be ye stedfast, unmoveable, always abounding in the work of the Lord, forasmuch as ye know that your labour is not in vain in the Lord” (1 Corinthians 15.58.) Our stories are not written into Revelation as a book in the canon. That distinction is Job’s to enjoy. But each Christian is written in the book of life alongside the ‘yokefellows’ and ‘fellowlabourers’ of the Lord (Philippians 4.3) and each one can have an assurance of that by the Holy Ghost on this side of the grave. This assurance happened one time in a Brethren study group that I was in. While we were discussing ‘how wonderful to be one of the persons mentioned in Romans 16’ in the list that is given there, the Spirit came gently down upon us as if to say: “Romans 16 is just a shortlist; I ‘salute’ you with ‘an holy kiss.’” 

The life that is gained through Christ is as far above what is mortal as his sacrifice is greater than our death; our death is made stingless by his. While Job may be a type of Christ, Christ is the way of life, for his obedience unto death has merited heaven for appropriators of his blood.


PART II, ARTICLE X: MASS MEDIA SORCERY, SECTION VI

Here is an example from Canada of the mass media sorcery that I am talking about. In March of 2020, anti-petroleum anarchists are blocking r...